CW Nevius thinks the votes are there, but it is a meaningless vote, as it will not survive a Mayoral veto or a court challenge.
Still, in the years I have been following this clusterfork, this is the first time I recall that the full board has voted directly on the issue at hand. I understand there will be no public comment, but wanted to see an actual vote, meaningful or not. So I'm back in City Hall to watch it happen.
Listening to Avalos now, he is softening the language considerably with an amendment. This is apparently intended to solve the EIR legal issue.
Now David Chiu is offering another Amendment to further soften the language.
Both are saying that now this ordinance is only assuring that all options are being explored - including destroying the course and giving it away to the feds. Sean Elsbernd calls bullshit. He says these amendments are eyewash - meant to disguise the real purpose of the ordinance. I trust Elsbernd, but it looks like Chiu has the votes lined up.
The Supe roster is cued up for the ayes and nays:
Nevius was right. It passed 6-5
Not sure if I got the votes exactly right - will correct later if I missed it [CORRECTED]:
AYE - John Avalos District 11 John.Avalos@sfgov.org
AYE - David Campos District 9 David.Campos@sfgov.org
AYE - David Chiu District 3 David.Chiu@sfgov.org
NO - Carmen Chu District 4 Carmen.Chu@sfgov.org
NO - Malia Cohen District 10 Malia.Cohen@sfgov.org
NO - Sean Elsbernd District 7 Sean.Elsbernd@sfgov.org
NO - Mark Farrell District 2 Mark.Farrell@sfgov.org
AYE - Jane Kim District 6 Jane.Kim@sfgov.org
AYE - Eric Mar District 1 Eric.L.Mar@sfgov.org
AYE - Ross Mirkarimi District 5 Ross.Mirkarimi@sfgov.org
NO - Scott Wiener District 8 Scott.Wiener@sfgov.org
Like I've said before. No one who casts a vote to give away this park deserves to serve in any public capacity in the City. But, it is axiomatic we get the government we deserve. We elect them, we have no one to blame but ourselves.
It is a 6-5 vote. One vote changes the outcome. Mirkarimi will be off the board in the new year. That is a very good thing. He can do less damage as Sheriff than what he can do on the Board. Eric Mar is up for reelection and vulnerable. He is out of step with his district and constituency. A concerted effort and he'll be off the board this time next year.
My understanding is that this was a vote on "First Reading." It must be submitted to another vote, probably next week, for the ordinance to pass. The language of the ordinance cannot change between first and final, or the process starts over. The way they threw last minute changes at this, it's possible that a detailed reading will find a flaw that will push this into next year with Mirkarimi off the board. If that does not happen a veto by Mayor Ed Lee is the next best hope. There are not enough votes on the board to overcome a Lee veto.
Nevius was right about the board vote. Hopefully he is also right about a Lee veto.
On to the next round.
Corrected typos, fixed the vote count, added thoughts and links.
Sent from my HTC smartphone on the Now Network from Sprint!
MW Mobile Blog
For friends, family and the random search engine visitor. This blog started as an experiment in mobile blogging from my
Palm TREO 600 700 Prē HTC Evo,Samsung 5. Now it serves as a simple repository of favorite activities. Expect bad golf, good fishing, great sailing, eating, drinking, adventure travel, occasional politics and anything else I find interesting along the way including, but not limited to, any of the labels listed here...
MW BLOG LABEL CLOUD (click label for posts on that topic)
abalone Africa America's Cup art Azores baja baseball bass beer Burkina Faso Cabo Caribbean Cascais Chicago China Chitwan critters Cubs da bears Dogon drink Egypt Escanaba River Ethiopia Family Fishing Five Forties food forestry France From the Terrace Ganges River golf Gualala River Hawaii Himalayas hunting ice fishing India Japan Jordan Kathmandu kayak Kobe Kyoto Lake Kariba Lincoln Park London Mali Mexico Michigan Monterey Morpheus Morpheus Atlantic Passage Nepal New Delhi Niger River Osaka Pacific panorama Paris pike politics Portugal protests rainbow Ranthambore recipe river Russian Hill ryokan Sahara Desert Sailing salmon San Francisco Sea Ranch Senegal SF Power Tour Sharp Park spider sunrise sunset Tech Thanksgiving The Golf War Timbuktu Travel trout tuna UNESCO World Heritage Site Varanasi WTF yooper Zambezi River Zimbabwe